Shedding Light: The Negative Effects of Outdoor Lighting – monthly column featured in Sparks Electrical News (Crown Publications)

Visit Sparks Magazine here to read more

Have you ever taken a moment to look up at the stars? Perhaps during lockdown when there was significantly less air pollution, you may have looked up at the skies and been surprised to see more stars that you are normally able to see. There have recently been several astronomical events that took place. If you were like me, you probably were not able to see many of them. I am sure it was not for lack of trying, but rather due to high levels of skyglow caused by high levels of city light.

Whatever happened to the stars everyone talks about so passionately?

During the lockdown period, I was approached and subsequently commissioned as a specialist consultant and educator to investigate two similar, yet different, cases.

The first case involved a closed upmarket housing estate in KwaZulu-Natal where the body corporate and managing agents decided to task an electrical contractor to install lighting to provide general exterior lighting to double as security lighting.

The lighting that was installed, however, was completely inappropriate for either of the purposes. Fluorescent tubes in corrosion proof IP65 luminaires were installed. They were mounted horizontally on the face of the external walls of some houses. The result was diabolical. In some houses, the only room that was unaffected by the obtrusive light, was the bathroom!

The second case in the Cape Metropole involved excessive illumination of a green belt which separated two neighbourhoods, and which continued on into the greater area of a vast nature reserve. In this instance, the local authority had been approached by some members of each neighbourhood to install lighting for improved security. Once again, the local authority tasked a private electrical contractor to install the flood lighting which was totally inappropriate for the purpose. So, what went wrong?

Firstly, both the body corporate/managing agent in Case 1 and the local authority in Case 2, should have engaged a qualified illumination engineer to conduct a survey, risk and environmental impact assessment on the fauna and flora of the area. This would have led to the appropriate luminaires being selected and then correctly installed in the correct places fit for purpose.

In the case of the illumination in the green belt, the local authority should have compiled a master plan that included the environmental zoning of various parts of the city for the type of lighting, if any, according to the CIE (International Commission for Illumination) CUIE150 and MLO (Model Lighting Ordinance) which includes the requirements for compliance with IDA (The International Dark Sky Association).

The Zones are as follows: SQM is Sky Quality Measurement, in other simple words, how many stars can be seen. Case 1 would fall within Zone E3 whereas Case 2 would fall within Zone E1 to E2.

  • In Case 1, the lighting had to be removed and replaced with the appropriate lower wattage luminaires with all light directed downwards and away from the homes to avoid any obtrusive lighting. It is also interesting to note that obtrusive lighting used to be known as ‘light trespass’ (it is still referred in that way in South African National Standards which are overdue for revision and updating). The CIE ruled that it is no longer to be referred to as ‘light trespass’ but now as ‘nuisance light’, which is exactly what it was in Case 1, and to a certain extent, in Case 2. My findings in my detailed report were fully supported by the local authority in KwaZulu-Natal.
  • In Case 2, which has not yet been rectified by the local authority, a large number of small animal and nesting bird species inhabited the area. Most of these moved further away when the flood lights were installed. Furthermore, many residents complained when they could no longer see the night sky clearly because of the ‘new’ contribution to skyglow which previously barely existed.

Conclusion

The world is increasingly becoming aware of the need to act against climate change, and this includes the negative effects of outdoor lighting, which includes street lighting and all other forms of outdoor lighting. Of course, bright sport field lighting, which is only used when games take place, is excluded. It is alarming to note the number of professional engineers and local authority electrical engineers who are completely unaware of the importance of having a thorough knowledge of all standards, regulations and other requirements.

Philip Hammond


BHA SCHOOL OF LIGHTING – 21 SEPTEMBER 2020

Copyright © 2020 Crown Publications (Pty) Ltd, All rights reserved.

Copyright © 2020 BHA Lighting Design & Consulting and BHA School of Lighting, All rights reserved.

Our mailing address is:

BHA School of Lighting

20 Arena North, Grand National Blvd

Royal Ascot

Cape Town, Western Cape

South Africa

7441